Caciocavallo all’Argentiera – Caciocavallo Cheese, Sicilian Recipe


This is a recipe that will make you smile 🙂 and it will turn a simple dinner into something very delicious.

I still have a good amount of caciocavallo Ragusano DOP at home, from the last time I came back from Italy, and I love that cheese.

This cheese is obviously perfect as it is, but you can make a lot of delicious Sicilian recipes with it, and this is definitely a nice one.

But let me tell you its story (or legend) first, which is quite interesting and funny.

The origin of this dish, according to an anectode I read more times, is in Palermo. These origins date back to the times when the Argenteria street was inhabited by the silversmiths (argentieri), so over 100 years ago for sure. At that time the silversmiths were considered very rich because they worked silver and gold, although in the reality it was not always that way. What was making them look rich was the fire that remained lit all day long in their houses because of their work, and at that time many people couldn’t afford that. It is said that one of them, fallen in disgrace, had a very talented wife in the kitchen, and a day his wife, to show off to the neighbors and not to make it clear to them that they were no more wealthy as before, prepared this dish that had a smell similar to the smell of the cooked rabbit. So, when the smell arrived in the street, she made believe that nothing had changed, compared to the past times, when they could afford to cook also the rabbit. The trick was that instead of rabbit she used the cheaper caciocavallo, and the aroma that arose from the fusion with garlic, cheese and vinegar, had nothing to envy to the more expensive dish 🙂 Today this recipe became part of the traditional Sicilian cuisine, and in the very past time it was often called “cunigghiu (rabbit) all’argentiera” 🙂 but nowadays it is called for what it is, caciocavallo.

As I said I used the Ragusano DOP, but also the caciocavallo palermitano is an option, or other caciocavallo types.

You need very few ingredients, and it’s very fast to prepare. Let’s see.


INGREDIENTS (2 people):

  • 200 g caciocavallo cheese, semistagionato (semi-matured, 4-6 months, and I suggest slices of about 1 cm thick)
  • extra virgin olive oil
  • white wine vinegar
  • 2 anchovies, salt cured (or 4 fillets if kept in olive oil)
  • dried oregano
  • 1 clove of garlic
  • some flour


  1. Cut the cheese, then pass it in some flour, not too much.
  2. Take a pan, better if in iron/cast iron, and heat some extra virgin olive oil, not too much. then add the crushed garlic.
  3. Meanwhile take a small glass and add 2 fingers of extra virgin olive oil and 2 fingers of white wine vinegar (or a bit less). Add also the dried oregano and mix.
  4. Now remove the garlic and add the slices of caciocavallo in the pan, at medium heat. Cook for few minutes until there is some crust on the bottom. Then turn it on the other side. It will be crunchy outside and softer in the middle.caciocavallo_argentiera_2
  5. When it’s ready place the cheese in your dishes, then set the heat higher and add the extra virgin olive oil, vinegar and oregano mixture. Cook until reduced (1 minute probably is enough), and then pour it over the caciocavallo cheese.
  6. Add also the anchovies.
  7. Enjoy 🙂




4 Comments Add yours

  1. Karen says:

    While I know I won’t be able to find the cheese where we live, I can still imagine what a treat it is to eat…tasting of cheese and smelling of rabbit.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, and dangerous because you can eat too much 😀

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Lo era 😀 grazie!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s